Homemade eggnog: cook the egg base to 160°F, because rum won't make raw eggs safe
A classic eggnog recipe whisks raw eggs into milk, sugar and often rum. The USDA and the FDA both say fresh eggs, even clean ones with uncracked shells, may carry Salmonella, and the USDA lists eggnog made from eggs that aren't thoroughly cooked among the foods everyone is advised against. The fix is simple: egg mixtures are safe once they reach 160°F, so cook the eggs with part of the milk first. [S1] [S2]
Our take: cook the eggs and half the milk to 160°F on a food thermometer every time, even if your eggs are pasteurized, then chill the base before you add anything else. Treat the rum as flavor, not safety, and put the bowl back in the fridge within 2 hours. That's our reading of the federal and extension guidance, not a promise about any one recipe. [S1] [S2] [S4] [S6]
Is this eggnog plan safe?
| Situation | What the sources say | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| A recipe with raw eggs and no cooking | Federal food safety pages advise against eggnog made from egg ingredients that aren't thoroughly cooked | Cook the egg and milk base to 160°F first |
| Adding rum, bourbon or brandy | You can't count on the alcohol to kill the bacteria; heat is what does it | Cook the base anyway; the alcohol is for flavor |
| Cooking the egg and milk base | Egg mixtures are safe once they reach 160°F; heat gently and stir | Check 160°F with a food thermometer, then chill |
| Pasteurized shell eggs or egg products | Treated to destroy Salmonella; the FDA and USDA still suggest a cooked base for the most safety | Look for "pasteurized" on the carton; cooking the base is still the safest call |
| A recipe that folds in raw beaten whites | Raw beaten whites can't be guaranteed safe | Use pasteurized whites, whipped cream or whipped topping |
| Store-bought eggnog | Often already cooked or pasteurized; check the label to be sure | Read the carton, keep it cold, and follow its date |
| Stirring raw-egg nog into hot coffee | The coffee cools too much to make it safe | Start with a cooked base instead |
| The bowl has been out for 2 hours | Egg dishes go back in the fridge within 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90°F | Refrigerate it, or serve it on ice |
Eggs and half the milk to 160°F. Chill, then finish the recipe.
Why raw eggs are the risk
- Clean shells aren't enough. The FDA says fresh eggs, even those with clean, uncracked shells, may contain Salmonella bacteria. [S2]
- It can start inside the egg. The USDA says Salmonella Enteritidis can contaminate an egg inside the hen, before the shell even forms, and can be in the yolk, the white or on the shell. [S1]
- Eggnog is on the list. The USDA advises everyone against raw or undercooked eggs, naming eggnog made from egg ingredients that are not thoroughly cooked alongside homemade mayonnaise, ice cream and Caesar dressing. [S1]
- What it feels like. The FDA says most people infected with Salmonella get diarrhea, fever, stomach cramps and vomiting 12 to 72 hours later, usually for 4 to 7 days, and most recover without treatment. [S2]
- Who is most at risk. The USDA and FDA name infants and young children, older adults, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems as most vulnerable to severe illness. [S1] [S2]
Cook the egg base to 160°F
- Eggs plus half the milk. The FDA's eggnog advice is to combine the eggs and half the milk the recipe calls for; sugar can go in at this step too. [S4]
- Low heat, constant stirring. Heat the mixture gently, stirring constantly, the USDA and FDA say. Kansas State's extension service suggests a large heavy saucepan or a double boiler to prevent scorching. [S1] [S4] [S6]
- 160°F on a thermometer. The USDA says egg mixtures are safe if they reach 160°F and to use a food thermometer, and the FDA's party fact sheet says the same for adapting old family recipes. Our food thermometer guide covers checking one. [S1] [S3]
- The spoon test is a clue, not proof. The FDA column says the base firmly coats a metal spoon at about this temperature. Our take: use the coating as a sign you're close, and the thermometer as the answer. [S4]
- Chill before you finish. Chill the cooked base before adding the rest of the milk and other ingredients, the FDA column says. Washington State University's sample recipe sets the pan in a bowl of ice or cold water and stirs for about 10 minutes, then refrigerates it until thoroughly chilled. For a big batch, the FDA says shallow containers cool faster. [S2] [S4]
- Wash up after raw egg. Wash your hands, utensils and work surfaces with hot, soapy water before and after they touch raw eggs, the FDA says. [S2]
Rum, bourbon and hot coffee don't count
- Alcohol isn't a kill step. The FDA column says that if contaminated, unpasteurized eggs go into eggnog, you can't count on the alcohol in the drink to kill all of the bacteria. Kansas State's food safety specialist puts it more bluntly: alcohol does not kill bacteria, and heat is the only way. [S4] [S6]
- Hot coffee isn't either. Kansas State says adding raw-egg eggnog to hot coffee won't make it safe, because the temperature drops too much. [S6]
- Make a batch without alcohol. The FDA column specifically mentions non-alcoholic eggnog for young children and pregnant women. Our take: if kids are coming, make a separate batch without alcohol from the same cooked base. [S4]
Pasteurized eggs, egg products and raw whites
- What pasteurized means. Minnesota's extension service says pasteurized shell eggs are gently heated by a research-tested process that inactivates Salmonella without cooking them. The carton says "pasteurized," and the eggs may be stamped with a P. [S5]
- Where to find them. The FDA lists fresh pasteurized eggs in the shell and liquid pasteurized egg products in the refrigerator section, frozen egg products in the freezer section and powdered egg whites in the baking aisle. Minnesota's extension says liquid and dried egg products are always pasteurized. [S3] [S5]
- Read the carton. The FDA says eggs that haven't been treated to destroy Salmonella must carry a safe handling statement; treated eggs don't need it, and their label usually says they were treated. [S2]
- You can't do it at home. The USDA says pasteurizing equipment isn't available for home use, and it's very difficult to pasteurize shell eggs at home without cooking them. [S1]
- Still cook the base. The USDA says pasteurized in-shell eggs may be used safely without cooking, but the FDA column says both the FDA and the USDA recommend starting with a cooked base even with pasteurized eggs, for the most safety. [S1] [S4]
- Raw beaten whites. The USDA says recipes made with raw, beaten egg whites can't be guaranteed safe and suggests pasteurized dried egg whites, whipped cream or whipped topping instead. [S1] [S5]
Serving it and keeping leftovers
- Two hours out, tops. The FDA says never to leave egg dishes out of the fridge for more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour above 90°F, because bacteria grow quickly between 40°F and 140°F. [S2] [S3]
- Serve it cold. The FDA says to keep cold foods at 40°F or colder and to put cold egg dishes on ice if they'll be out longer than 2 hours. Our potluck guide covers the same clock for any dish you bring. [S2] [S3]
- Fridge at 40°F. Keep the refrigerator at 40°F or below and check it with a fridge thermometer, the FDA says. Minnesota's extension says the door is the warmest spot, so keep eggs off it. [S2] [S5]
- How long it keeps. The USDA's storage chart gives homemade eggnog 2 to 4 days in the fridge and says not to freeze it. Commercial eggnog gets 3 to 5 days in the fridge or 6 months in the freezer. [S1]
- Store-bought nog. Kansas State says store-bought eggnog is pasteurized; the FDA says store-bought versions are often already cooked or pasteurized and to check the label to be sure. Our take: read the carton and follow its date. [S3] [S6]
Where the sources line up
Every source agrees on the main point: an eggnog base made with ordinary raw eggs should reach 160°F before you finish the recipe. They differ on the details. The USDA says pasteurized in-shell eggs may be used safely without cooking, while the FDA column says both agencies still recommend a cooked base for the most safety. Kansas State says store-bought eggnog is pasteurized, while the FDA says store-bought foods are often cooked or pasteurized and to check the label. The USDA storage chart doesn't say whether its eggnog times start at purchase or at opening. Page dates differ too: the USDA page was last updated November 20, 2024, the FDA egg page is current as of March 5, 2024, the FDA fact sheet is dated January 2017, the Washington State sheet reprints a December 21, 2010 FDA column, Minnesota's page was reviewed in 2026 and Kansas State's column is from December 21, 2023. All six were read November 14, 2026. [S1] [S2] [S3] [S4] [S5] [S6]
Safe or not?
Pick what's going on with your eggnog. The answer puts what the USDA, the FDA and the extension pages say in one place. It's general guidance; a stricter rule on your recipe or carton comes first. [S1] [S2] [S4] [S6]
Choose an option to start.
Eggnog checklist
Before the party
Quick answers
Does rum or bourbon make raw-egg eggnog safe?
No. The FDA column says you can't count on the alcohol to kill all of the bacteria from contaminated eggs, and Kansas State says alcohol does not kill bacteria. Cook the base to 160°F. [S4] [S6]
How do I keep the base from curdling or scorching?
Cook it gently over low heat and keep stirring, the USDA says. Washington State's sheet says the eggs are likely to curdle if the base goes past 160°F, and Kansas State suggests a heavy saucepan or double boiler to prevent scorching. [S1] [S4] [S6]
Do I need to cook eggnog made with pasteurized eggs?
The USDA says pasteurized in-shell eggs may be used without cooking, but the FDA column says both agencies still recommend a cooked base for the most safety. Our take: cook it anyway. [S1] [S4]
Is store-bought eggnog safe without cooking?
Kansas State says store-bought eggnog is pasteurized, and the FDA says store-bought foods like it are often already cooked or pasteurized; check the label to be sure. [S3] [S6]
How long does homemade eggnog last?
The USDA chart says 2 to 4 days in the refrigerator, and not to freeze it. [S1]
Is anything ranked here?
No. This guide explains USDA, FDA and university extension guidance. It doesn't rank or endorse any eggnog, egg brand or tool, and nothing was tested for it. Related NBB guides, like the one on raw cookie dough, are linked only for deeper reading.
Sources
USDA, FDA and university extension pages checked November 14, 2026. Recommendations here are our editorial reading of those pages; no hands-on results are claimed.
- S1 · USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service: Shell Eggs from Farm to Table (Last updated November 20, 2024 (shown on page; read November 14, 2026))
- S2 · U.S. Food and Drug Administration: What You Need to Know About Egg Safety (Content current as of March 5, 2024 (shown on page; read November 14, 2026))
- S3 · U.S. Food and Drug Administration: Food Facts, Serving Up Safe Buffets (January 2017 (printed on the fact sheet; read November 14, 2026))
- S4 · Washington State University Extension: Homemade Eggnog, Make it Safely (reprint of an FDA consumer column) (Uploaded December 2020; credits Nancy Bufano, FDA Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition, December 21, 2010 (read November 14, 2026))
- S5 · University of Minnesota Extension: Purchase, store, and prepare: Eggs (Reviewed in 2026 by an Extension food safety educator (shown on page; read November 14, 2026))
- S6 · Kansas State University Research and Extension: Eggnog Tips for Ringing in the New Year! (Published Thursday, December 21, 2023, by Karen Blakeslee (shown on page; read November 14, 2026))